Project breakdown start to finish, Insulation vs. ventilation
I would like to launch into a series of topics for discussion starting with foundations and working through each phase of a project to completion, but first to launch this endeavour I would like to do something to honor the current weather conditions and how it affects us. This is a sample of the topics to come, please feel free to submit any topic suggestions that you would like discussed during this series.
Attic ventilation and insulation is something most people never have much cause to think about, for single family and multifamily structures already completed there are ways to check if your attic is functioning properly, for new construction the same checks apply. Why is this important? 1. Heating & cooling loss = $$ out of your pocket 2. Damage can occur from ice damming and condensation 3.dry rot from insufficient venting. So what causes these issues? the concept of the conventional roof system is to insulate the ceiling (currently R-38 for attics is code) and vent the space above. Keeping the temperature of the attic close to the same temperature as the outside is very important.If the outside air is colder than the attic then cold air enters the attic through the improperly vented roof system it hits the warmer air and freezes any moisture in the warmer air. The other thing that happens is any metal (roofing nails, cast iron vent pipes etc.) that penetrate the roof into the attic do what is called thermal bridging, you may have seen something like this on aluminum windows where condensation freezes on the inside of the frames then melts creating a mess, roofing nails through the roof will rust and eventually allow water to leak in.
What’s the solution? first check to see what the depth of your insulation is, bat and blown in insulation is typically R-3.75 per inch so an 8″bat or blown in depth = R-30 which is pretty good! Next check to see all ventilation is in place and clear (sometimes the insulation blocks off the eve vents) next make sure there is an airflow pathway such as eves to gable end or ridge vents and that they are sized properly for the space (venting charts are available), this will keep our attics cold and living space warm in the winter with proper insulation. During the summer it works in reverse, hot air is ventilated out of the attic limiting the heat gain into our homes through our roofs while eliminating dry dry rot issues. In extreme cases the damage caused requires full roof replacement, climates definately play into the “extremes” however the solutions are the same, check with a local design professional or building inspector to see what is recommended for you region.
Matt Stodola



Welcome to the 





January 14th, 2011 at 5:22 pm
Hi Matt,
I replaced my home’s roof a few years back, switching from wood shingles with about a dozen square vents to asphalt shingles with continuous ridge vent. I noticed the roofers capped off the vertical gable vents, leaving just the eave vent holes and the ridge vent. Would it be better to have the gable vents unblocked, or did they do the right thing? Also, how do you add more insulation in the attic without blocking the eave vents?
Thanks,
Ben
January 17th, 2011 at 5:46 pm
Hi Ben,
Yes, your roofing contractor did the right thing! For optimum performance you need a ventilation draw from the eves through the attic to either a ridge vent, square roof vent, or gable end vent. If you have gable end vents and then add a ridge vent or square roof vent you can get a draw from gable to the ridge/roof vents instead of from the eves. This is all dependent on the amount of ventilation coming from each area, ideally you want the eve vent area to equal the roof vent area for an even draw and good circulation.
As for the isulation question, the most typical solution is to install a baffle which is nailed between the rafters at the exterior wall line extending up about three feet. The baffles, most commonly manufactured from cardboard, create about a 2″ space from the roof sheeting and protect the eve venting from becoming obstructed from insulation.
Thanks for the comments,
Matt–